Page 76 - Beaumont Basin Watermaster - 2015 Annual Report
P. 76

1A.- Do areas with septic systems have different chemistry than areas with sewers?
                 The report indicates that there are statistically significant differences between groundwater in
                 areas with septic systems and groundwater where sewer service is available.  The
                 concentrations of PPCPs, TDS, Nitrate-N, the sum of base cations, Boron, and Isotopes of
                 Nitrate were all significantly higher in areas with septic systems than in areas with sewer
                 service.

                 1B.- Do areas where groundwater recharge with water from the State Water Project or
                 wastewater treatment plant effluent have different chemistry from other areas?

                 Strong evidence of nitrate deriving from human waste was detected in Zone 1 as well as
                 strong biological attenuation of nitrate transported in groundwater.


                 2.- What sources contribute nitrate to groundwater of the BMZ?
                 The report indicates that in Zone 1 the isotopes of nitrate values overlap those expected for
                 human or animal waste.  Similarly, in Zone 3 the isotopic composition of water suggest a high
                 probability of inputs of nitrate from human or animal waste.  The presence of PPCPs in most
                 samples indicates the possibility that septic systems are contaminating groundwater within the
                 central part of Cherry Valley.

                 3.- How much nitrate from human waste is making its way into the groundwater of the BMZ?

                 The report documents the following findings:

                    ƒ  Mixing models suggest that between 18 to 30 percent of the nitrate in central Cherry
                        Valley groundwater is derived from septic systems.
                    ƒ  If septic systems were completely phased out, nitrate concentrations in central Cherry
                        Valley groundwater could decline by 30 percent once a steady state condition is
                        achieved.  The time to reach a steady state is anticipated to be shorter than in other
                        portions of the BMZ due to relatively high rates of recharge in Zone 3.
                    ƒ  Mass balance calculations show that nitrate-nitrogen inputs from septic systems is one
                        of the largest inputs of nitrogen to groundwater in the BMZ.
                    ƒ  If the waste from septic tanks were to be conveyed to the City of Beaumont WWTP,
                        about 30 percent of the current input of nitrate from human waste to groundwater
                        would be removed.

                 4.2      Comparison with Federal and State Drinking Water
                          Standards

                 The California Department of Health Services (CDPH) maintains an active water quality
                 database of all public and private drinking water wells throughout the state.  This database,
                 available at CDPH’s website, was assessed for the 2011-2015 reporting period for 21
                 domestic production wells in the Beaumont Basin.  The objective of this analysis was to
                 determine whether any of these potable wells had exceeded the Primary or Secondary
                 Federal and State standards or the notification levels set by the state.  Federal standards are
                 set by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) while state standards in
                 California are set by CDPH.   Primary standards at the federal and state level are enforceable



                  Beaumont Basin Watermaster 2015 Annual Report – Final – December 2016                  4-5
   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78   79   80   81